Showing posts with label Causation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Causation. Show all posts

Thursday, December 29, 2011

Holiday Season Food Law (Part IV): The food poisoning cases

(This is the fourth post in my holiday series in which I am surveying South Carolina's products liability case law involving food/beverage.  See also part I, part II, and part III). 

As Christmas is behind us and New Year's Day is around the corner, it seems appropriate to begin bringing this series to a conclusion by talking about food that just flat out makes you sick. 

This Saturday evening, people around the world will ring in 2012 with all sorts of food and beverage, and undoubtedly some of them will just become sick for no apparent reason (other than maybe imbibing a bit too much).  There is another line of cases in South Carolina where the lawsuit relates to food that just made someone sick...no fragments of glass, no exploding bottles, no animal carcasses in the food.  The plaintiff just eats/drinks something and gets food poisoning of some variation.  If you are one of these unfortunate individuals, this post is dedicated to you.

In Gantt v. Columbia Coca-Cola Bottling Co., 193 S.C. 51, 7 S.E.2d 641 (1940), a man became sick after drinking a soft drink he believed contained some kind of poisonous substance.  Only after analysis by some chemists was it determined that the soft drink contained copper sulphate (which apparently is used by farmers to protect crops from rust).  7 S.E.2d at 642.  The plaintiff sued for negligence (in bottling of the soft drink, inspection, etc.), and the jury awarded $2,000.  Id.  On appeal, the defendant argued (1) there was no evidence it bottled the drink or that it contained the substance at the time of bottling, and (2) there was no evidence from which a jury could conclude it was negligent.  Id. at 643.  In a detailed opinion, the court pointed out that the only evidence of negligence was a violation of the applicable Pure Food Statute at the time (i.e., making it negligence per se if there is some poisonous or deleterious substance in the food).  Id.  It did not matter that the plaintiff failed to plead the statute in his Complaint, and "neither knowledge of the contamination nor negligence in fact is a material element of the offense."  Id.  It is negligence per se under the law, and this alone is sufficient for consideration by the jury.  Id. at 645.  However, the court reversed the case and remanded for a new trial.  Id. at 645-46.  Why?  Because the trial judge excluded testimony by the defendant the instance at issue was the only time that copper sulphate had been found in the soft drink bottled by the defendant.  Id. at 646.  In short, if the plaintiff can get the case to the jury by just showing violation of the statute, the defendant also should be able to offer testimony relevant to the standard of care, and failure to allow this testimony required a new trial.

Yummy processed and potted meat.  Love it.  My dad's generation sure did, as I often heard stories of "eating Vi-enner sausages in the field" while growing up.  I will pass, thank you very much (especially after reading Upton Sinclair's The Jungle in my high school history class).  Nevertheless, there are three South Carolina cases I have found involving potted/processed meat, and reading them is pure entertainment.  

Housand v. Armour & Co., 173 S.C. 268, 175 S.E. 516 (1934) involved consumption of "oil sausage" sold in 50-pound cans and retrieved via "an old fork which hung from the counter" in the retail shop."  175 S.E. at 517.  This is a strange case in which the "defendant" Armour was found to not actually be the right defendant, but they answered and went to trial anyway.  Ultimately, the judgment against the defendant corporation was reversed based on lack of evidence of negligence and improper expert testimony.  Id. at 518.  The court affirmed the judgment against the local defendants based on how they handled the meat (i.e., not keeping it refrigerated).  Id. at 518-20.  Hollis v. Armour & Co., 190 S.C. 170, 2 S.E.2d 681 (1939) also involved oil sausages, and the offending sausages in this case were sold from cans that had rusted.  The concept of preemption rears its head in this early case, as one of the defendant's arguments was that the State Pure Food Statute interfered with federal acts and regulations.  2 S.E.2d at 684-85.  The court disagreed, and it also believed the plaintiff had adequately pled a violation of the State Pure Food Statute so as to sustain the $1,500 award by the jury to the plaintiff.  Id. at 685.  Finally, Boylston v. Armour & Co., 196 S.C. 1, 12 S.E.2d 34 (1940) involved a ham that had a "bluish-greenish cast" that is "not unusual" in a cooked, smoked ham.  12 S.E.2d at 37.  (Uhhh...okay).  Contrary to the holding in Hollis, the Boylston court reversed the trial court and remanded the case for a new trial on grounds that the applicable State Pure Food Statute did not apply; it only applied to manufacture or sale or offer for sale of food within the state, and there was evidence that the meat at issue was prepared and sold out of state.  Id. at 38. 

Poor Armour.  These cases are a mixed-up potted mess, and reading them can be exhausting.  The above summary does not do them justice.  If you have an interest in potted meat cases, I encourage you to read them for yourself.

Last but not least, Fowler v. Coastal Coca-Cola Bottling Co., 252 S.C. 579, 167 S.E.2d 572 (1969) involved a three-year-old child who became sick after drinking a soft drink that contained something "dark in color and slick and slimy to the touch."  A pathologist determined that the substance was yeast, and he testified that certain yeasts can cause certain diseases.  Id. at 582, 167 S.E.2d at 574.  The problem was that the plaintiff's doctor testified there had been a rash of viruses at the time, and he could not say whether the plaintiff's sickness was from the virus or from the yeast in the soft drink.  Id. at 583, 167 S.E.2d at 574.  Although the court recognized a violation of the Pure Food and Drug Act in effect at the time constituted negligence per se, the plaintiff still had to show proximate causation. 
We have held that where the cause of plaintiff's injury may be as reasonably attributed to an act for which the defendant is not liable as to one for which he is liable, the plaintiff has failed to carry the burden of establishing that his injury was the proximate result of defendant's negligence.
Id. at 575, 167 S.E.2d at 584.  Based on this law, the court reversed the judgment because plaintiff failed to prove proximate causation.

This is the last group of cases in this series.  In my next (concluding) post for this series, I will do my best to synthesize my blogs on food and beverage case law and bring some "order" to them.

Happy New Year!

This post is subject to the DISCLAIMER AND TERMS OF USE of this website.

Wednesday, July 15, 2009

Case Brief: Allen v. Long Mfg. NC, Inc.

Today's case brief is of Allen v. Long, Mfg. NC, Inc., 332 S.C. 422, 505 S.E.2d 354 (Ct. App. 1998). This is a warnings case, and it is significant because it discusses the adequacy of warnings, rejects that compliance with industry standards is conclusive evidence of adequacy, and establishes the heeding presumption in South Carolina.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND: Otis Allen, Sr. ("Allen") was using a portable grain auger to load grain onto a grain drill. 332 S.C. at 424, 505 S.E.2d at 355. The auger's center of gravity could change when grain was conveyed to the top of the auger without replacing the material at the bottom (which kept it stable and prevented it from becoming top heavy). Id. Allen was standing beneath the auger's discharge end when it became unstable and struck him in the head, killing him. Id. He had not anchored the lower end or supported the discharge end. Id. The auger contained a warning label with the word "CAUTION" preceding eleven different instructions. 332 S.C. at 425, 505 S.E.2d at 356.

PROCEDURE: Allen's estate ("Plaintiff") brought a wrongful death and pain and suffering action against Defendant Long Mfg. NC, Inc. ("Long", the manufacturer of the auger) and Glen Kinard, the auger's owner. 332 S.C. at 424-25, 505 S.E.2d at 355. The theories of recovery were strict liability and negligence. Id. at 424, 505 S.E.2d at 355. The trial court granted Long's motion for summary judgment. Id. Plaintiff appealed to the South Carolina Court of Appeals.

ISSUES: The questions on appeal were whether genuine issues of material fact existed regarding (1) whether the auger was in a "defective condition unreasonably dangerous" to Allen, (2) whether Long breached its duty of care by failing to provide an adequate warning, and (3) whether Allen's failure to follow the warning was the proximate cause of his injuries. 332 S.C. at 425-26, 505 S.E.2d at 356.

DISPOSITION: The Court of Appeals reversed the trial court's grant of summary judgment. 332 S.C. at 426, 505 S.E.2d at 356. It found that the sufficiency of the auger's warnings was a question of fact for the jury. Id.

RULES AND OPINION: With regard to whether the auger was in a defective condition, unreasonably dangerous to the user, the court pointed out that "[i]f a warning is given which, if followed, makes the product safe for use, the product cannot be deemed defective or unreasonably dangerous." 332 S.C. at 427, 505 S.E.2d at 357 (citing Restatement (Second) of Torts section 402A cmt. j (1965)). Whether a warning is adequate is a question of fact for the jury as long as evidence has been presented that the warning was not adequate. Id. at 428, 505 S.E.2d at 357. Plaintiff's expert provided testimony regarding the auger's warning that created a genuine issue of material fact. 332 S.C. at 429, 505 S.E.2d at 358. There was nothing in the auger's warnings to explain that the machine's center of gravity could change as it emptied. Id. Furthermore, the court disagreed with the trial court's interpretation of Bragg v. Hi-Ranger, Inc., 319 S.C. 531, 462 S.E.2d 321 (Ct. App. 1996) as establishing that a warning is adequate as a matter of law if it complies with industry standards. 332 S.C. at 430-31, 505 S.E.2d at 358-59 ("We reject this principle as unsound since it would allow the industry to set its own standard of safety, a proposition which finds no support from other jurisdictions, and which is antithetical to the underlying premise of strict liability."). Finally, the court stated that it need not address whether a feasible design alternative must be presented to survive summary judgment. Id. at 431, 505 S.E.2d at 359. The court agreed that Plaintiff failed to present a factual issue on this point, but it concluded that the court erred in ruling upon it because Long conceded that the auger required a warning to be made safe. Id. This concession foreclosed Plaintiff's argument that the auger could have been redesigned to be made safer and rendered the trial court's holding moot. Id. at 431-32, 505 S.E.2d at 359.

With regard to Long's duty of care, the court reversed the trial court's determination that Long satisfied its duty of care because its determination was premised on the legal adequacy of the auger's warning, which the Court of Appeals (supra) held was an issue of fact for the jury. Id. at 432, 505 S.E.2d at 359.

Finally, the court reversed the trial court's finding that the Plaintiff failed to introduce evidence of causation. 332 S.C. at 432-33, 505 S.E.2d at 359-60. At trial, Long successfully argued that Allen's failure to heed the auger's warning was the proximate cause of his injuries because Plaintiff's expert stated that if Allen had followed the warnings, the accident would not have occurred. Id. at 432, 505 S.E.2d at 359-60. The court stated that when an adequate warning is given, the manufacturer may assume that it will be heeded by the product user. Id. at 432-33, 505 S.E.2d at 360. However, the testimony by Plaintiff's expert created a factual issue as to whether a different, adequate warning could have changed Allen's conduct. Id. at 433, 505 S.E.2d at 360.

This post is subject to the DISCLAIMER & TERMS OF USE of this website.

Tuesday, June 30, 2009

Case Brief: Harris v. Rose's Stores, Inc.

Today's case brief is of Harris v. Rose's Stores, Inc., 315 S.C. 344, 433 S.E.2d 905 (Ct. App. 1993). This case stands for the principle that causation in a products liability case must be based on "probability," as opposed to mere "possibility."

FACTUAL BACKGROUND: A fire at a residence killed a minor child. 315 S.C. at 345, 433 S.E.2d at 906. The fire was alleged to have been caused by a ceiling fan. Id. The fan was sold by Defendant Rose's ("Rose's") to Defendant Edgar Gregory ("Gregory"), the landlord of the burned residence. Id.

PROCEDURE: Plaintiff Pamela Harris (personal representative deceased's estate and hereinafter, "Plaintiff") brought wrongful death and survival actions against Rose's under a products liability theory. 315 S.C. at 345, 433 S.E.2d at 906. The trial court granted Rose's motion for summary judgment on Plaintiff's claim and and on a cross-claim asserted by Gregory against Rose's. Id. Plaintiff appealed. Id.

ISSUE: Whether the trial court erred in granting summary judgment to Rose's based on Plaintiff's belief that she had produced sufficient circumstantial evidence that the ceiling fan, which the fire totally destroyed, was defective and a substantial contributing cause of the fire. 315 S.C. at 345, 433 S.E.2d at 906.

DISPOSITION: The South Carolina Court of Appeals held that the trial court's grant of summary judgment was proper. 315 S.C. at 347, 433 S.E.2d at 907.

RULES AND OPINION: Plaintiff relied on the deposition testimony of her expert witness and a non-expert to establish the elements of her case. 315 S.C. at 346, 433 S.E.2d at 906-07. The expert was unable to point to any direct evidence that the fan was defective and caused the fire. 315 S.C. at 346, 433 S.E.2d at 907. The most he could say was that it was "possible" that the fan caused the fire, with other factors being equally as likely to have caused it. Id. The non-expert also could not establish that the fan was the cause of the fire. Id. "Causation based upon a possibility rather than a probability is not sufficient for a plaintiff to recover in a products liability case." Id. (citing Am Law Prod Liab 3d section 4:34, at 44 (1987). On this basis, the court held that Plaintiff had not met her burden of proof in establishing that Rose's negligence was the proximate cause of the injuries. 315 S.C. at 346-47, 433 S.E.2d at 907.

This post is subject to the DISCLAIMER & TERMS OF USE of this website.