Showing posts with label Component Parts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Component Parts. Show all posts

Monday, February 21, 2011

Case Brief: Benford v. Berkeley Heating Co.

Today's case "brief" (I should call these "surveys" since they admittedly are never very "brief") is Benford v. Berkeley Heating Co., 258 S.C. 357, 188 S.E.2d 841 (Ct. App. 1972). The case involves a furnace and component blower switch that -- although found not to be defective in design -- combines with improper installation to cause a fire. There is some artful pleading and and election of remedies that influence the outcome of this case. It is not a case of "bad facts make bad law," as I do not disagree with the court's findings based on the theory of recovery. However, I am not sure that the outcome would be the same if this case was heard today or if the case asserted negligence or strict liability as a theory of recovery.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND: Berkeley Heating Company ("Berkeley") installed a furnace manufactured by The Trane Company ("Trane") in the crawlspace of a new home in August of 1977. 258 S.C. at 361, 188 S.E.3d at 842. The home burned on November 30, 1967. Id. As installed, the furnace's vent was only two and three-quarter inches from the pine joist where the fire originated. Id. Trane's manual required clearance of at least six inches between the heater's draft hood and the joist. Id. The manual also required that the flue pipe to be pitched upwards to facilitate escape of exhaust through a "short and direct route." Id. However, as installed by Berkeley, the flue pipe was ten feet long and made three ninety degree turns. Id. Two experts investigated the fire for Plaintiff Marvin Benford ("Plaintiff"). Id. The first expert did not find anything wrong with the furnace itself, but cited to three errors in the furnace's installation: (1) inadequate clearance between the draft hood and joist, (2) three ninety degree elbows in the vent connector, and (3) the down pitch of the vent connector to the chimney. Id. at 361-362, 188 S.E.2d at 842. Another expert investigated the case for Plaintiff in February of 1969. Id. at 362, 188 S.E.2d at 842. He concluded that the blower had not operated during the fire. Id.

PROCEDURE: After receiving the first expert's report, Plaintiff sued Berkeley alone in Charleston County. 258 S.C. at 362, 188 S.E.2d at 842. After the second expert's report, Plaintiff discontinued his Charleston County suit against Berkeley alone and commenced a lawsuit against Berkeley and Trane in Dorchester County. Id. Plaintiff sought recovery on several theories, including negligence and implied warranty. Id. Plaintiff alleged that the failure of the blower to operate caused the temperature to become higher than normal. Id. The higher temperature and faulty installation by Berkeley combined to cause the fire. Id. The trial court required Plaintiff to elect a remedy for recovery at the end of his testimony, and Plaintiff chose breach of implied warranty. Id. The jury found in favor Berkeley, but returned a verdict against Trane. Id. at 361, 188 S.E. 2d at 842. Trane appealed.

ISSUES: Whether the trial court erred in not granting Trane's motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict or for a new trial. 258 S.C. at 361, 188 S.E.2d at 842.

DISPOSITION: Reversed. "For the reasons stated, the only reasonable inference from the evidence is that the intervening independent negligence of Berkeley was not reasonably foreseeable by Trane and that the destruction of plaintiff's house was not a natural and probable result of the failure of the blower switch. Trane's motion for judgment Non obstante verdicto should have been granted." 258 S.C. 368, 188 S.E.2d at 846.

RULES AND OPINION: The court set forth the applicable law for breach of implied warranty as follows:
The vendor is answerable for breach of implied warranty incident to a sale, as for any breach of contract, "for whatever damages follow as a natural consequence and proximate result of his conduct, or which may be reasonably be supposed to have been within the contemplation of the parties at the time the contract was made as a probable result of a breach of it."

258 S.C. at 362, 188 S.E.2d at 843 (quoting Nat'l Tire & Rubb Co. v. Hoover, 128 S.C. 344, 347-48, 122 S.E. 858, 859 (1924)). Applying this law, liability only extends to consequences that would follow the breach in the usual course of events, i.e., events that are foreseeable. Id. The court found that there was sufficient evidence to support the verdict that the switch was defective when it left Trane's hands. Id. at 363, 188 S.E.2d at 843. The court therefore reviewed whether there was evidence to support that the fire was a natural and foreseeable consequence of Trane's breach of implied warranty. Id. In other words, the court reviewed whether Trane could have foreseen the fire as a probable and natural result of the failure of the blower switch. Id.

The court reviewed the normal function of the heater and determined that if the blower switch does not operate, the air inside the heat exchanger to the unit continues to to grow hotter instead of being expelled into the dust system. Id. at 364, 188 S.E.3d at 843. The unit can complete a cycle in this manner, but it is said to be "cycling on the limit switch" and the result is that the draft hood reaches a much higher peak temperature than it otherwise would during normal cycling. Id. at 364, 188 S.E.2d at 843-44. The limit switch's function is to prevent dangerous overheating. Id. at 364, 188 S.E.2d at 844. Be that as it may, the furnace is designed to run in this manner so that there is sufficient heat to prevent pipes from freezing if the blower fails while a family is away. Id.

Significantly, Plaintiff did not claim defective manufacture and design of the heater by Trane, or that the installation manual was inadequate. Id. at 365, 188 S.E.2d at 844. Plaintiff's sole claim against Trane was with regard to the defective blower switch. Id. His installation claim was directed solely at Berkeley. Id. The court found that in the absence of proof to the contrary, Plaintiff's evidence supported that Berkeley's improper installation "interrupted the normally foreseeable train of events linking manufacture with use." Id. Berkeley's installation did not "usually and naturally" precede the use of a furnace. Id. Therefore, "[u]nless there was evidence reasonably pointing to the conclusion that the defective blower switch alone would have caused the loss in natural course, the judgment must fall." Id. The court reviewed the testimony of Plaintiff's experts, and it could not find any such evidence. Id. at 365-68, 188 S.E.2d at 844-46. Plaintiff's first expert said that the defective blower switch would not have caused the fire without the faulty installation. Id. at 365-66, 188 S.E.2d at 844. Plaintiff's second expert admitted during his testimony that the faulty installation made the difference in the fire's ignition. Id. at 366-68, 188 S.E.2d at 844-46.

The court recognized that Trane anticipated that its blower may not work all the time for a variety of different reasons (e.g., clogging, etc.), so it was designed to cycle safely on the limit switch when properly installed. Id. at 368, 188 S.E.2d at 846. "Any evidence that the furnace cycling on the limit switch would have caused the fire, even if it had been installed in the manner directed by the manual, would have pointed to a defect in design as the cause of the fire, which is not charged as a ground of recovery." Id. Based on Plaintiff's theory of recovery, the court reversed the verdict.

This post is subject to the DISCLAIMER AND TERMS OF USE of this website.

Thursday, October 7, 2010

Case Brief: Nelson v. Coleman Co.

Today's case brief is Nelson v. Coleman Co., Inc., 249 S.C. 652, 155 S.E.2d 917 (Ct. App. 1967). This case involves a floor furnace and outlines a manufacturer's duty to test and inspect components in its products. It also discusses circumstantial evidence in a negligence case and the consequences of a defendant's failure to present its own evidence in response to a plaintiff's case. Specifically, although the decision admits that South Carolina does not recognize the Res Ipsa Loquitor doctrine, if a plaintiff is injured and provides circumstantial evidence to explain the cause of the injury, then a defendant proceeds at his own peril by not responding.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND: Plaintiff Homeowner purchased an oil burning floor furnace from Defendant Manufacturer through Defendant's authorized dealer. 249 S.C. at 655, 155 S.E.2d at 919. The dealer installed the furnace, and sixteen hours later, it emitted sparks and flames and destroyed the house and its contents. Id.

PROCEDURE: Plaintiff sued Defendant on negligence grounds. 249 S.C. at 655, 155 S.E.2d at 919. At trial, Defendant moved for nonsuit and directed verdict at the conclusion of Plaintiff's case, and without offering testimony or evidence of its own. Id. at 656, 155 S.E.2d at 919. The motions were denied, and the jury returned a verdict for Plaintiff. Id. Defendant moved for a judgment notwithstanding the verdict or a new trial, and both motions were denied. Id. Defendant appealed the denial of its motions by the trial court.

ISSUES: Defendant raised various different evidentiary and legal rulings as the basis for the appeal, including whether there was sufficient evidence of negligence and damages.

DISPOSITION: The South Carolina Supreme Court affirmed the rulings of the trial court. 249 S.C. at 662, 155 S.E.2d at 922.

RULES AND OPINION: The furnace was delivered from Defendant and installed at Plaintiff's residence without any changes to its condition. 249 S.C. at 655, 155 S.E.2d at 919. Plaintiff offered expert testimony that the fire was caused by a malfunctioning of the fuel regulator, which allowed oil to go into the burner and overflow and burn outside the furnace. Id. at 656, 155 S.E.2d at 919. Plaintiff's expert further testified that the defect in the fuel regulator was not apparent and could only be detected by testing conducted before shipping of the product. Id. at 657, 155 S.E.2d at 920. Defendant contended that the fuel regulator was manufactured by a third-party. Id. Although it was a component to Defendant's product, Defendant contended that it had no duty to test and inspect the component. Id. Even if it had a duty, Defendant contended there was no evidence that it failed to fulfill this duty. Id. The court stated the applicable law as follows:
It is generally held that a manufacturer who incorporates into his product a component made by another has a responsibility to test and inspect such component, and that his negligent failure properly to perform such duty renders him liable for injuries proximately caused thereby.
Id. In this context, the court believed that Plaintiff had provided sufficient circumstantial evidence to support that the fire was caused by the malfunctioning fuel regulator and that the defect could have been discovered by the Defendant with proper inspection and testing. Id. at 658, 155 S.E.2d at 920. Therefore, with regard to the sufficiency of evidence of negligence, there was no error in refusing the Defendant's motions. Id.

Defendant also contested whether Plaintiff had provided competent evidence to support a finding of money damages. Id. Plaintiff presented evidence that the reasonable value of items lost in the fire was $11,198.20, which included a list compiled by Plaintiff of the personal property lost in the fire. Id. at 659, 155 S.E.2d at 921. The court found that it was reasonable for Plaintiff to provide his own estimate of the value of the personal property, and there was no error in refusing Defendant's motions on grounds of insufficient evidence of damages. Id.

Defendant also contested that the trial judge erred in sustaining Plaintiff's objection to certain questions posed to Plaintiff's expert witness, i.e., "Is it customery in the trade for the manufacturers of these regulators to test them after they are manufactured." Id. at 660, 155 S.E.2d at 921. The court found that the trial judge's decision to sustain Plaintiff's objection to this question was not error because Defendant was able to pose a similar question to Plaintiff's expert and get his answer. Id. at 660-61, 155 S.E.2d at 921.

Defendant also asserted that Plaintiff's argument to the jury that Defendant had failed to produce witnesses or offer testimony was improper. Id. at 661, 155 S.E.2d at 922. The court disagreed, stating "We have held in a number of cases that it is proper for counsel to comment on the fact that the defendant has not taken the stand or offered testimony. It would be error in a criminal case so to do but not in a civil case. " Id. Therefore, the court held that this exception by Defendant was meritless. Id.

Finally, Defendant objected to the trial judge's charge that if a party fails to produce testimony of an available witness on a material issue, then the jury may infer that such testimony (if presented) would be adverse to the party failing to call the witness. Id. at 661-662, 155 S.E.2d at 922. Defendant's objection was that the trial judge left out the requirement that the witness be "available." Id. at 662, 155 S.E.2d at 922. However, the court found that Defendant had not properly preserved this objection at trial (i.e., Defendant did not request any clarification, amplification, or other curative measure by the trial judge). Id.

This post is subject to the DISCLAIMER AND TERMS OF USE of this website.
Italic

Monday, February 22, 2010

Case Brief: Scott v. Fruehauf Corp.

Today's case brief is Scott v. Fruehauf Corp., 302 S.C. 364, 396 S.E.2d 354 (1990). To be fairly short, this case is pretty substantive in terms of the number of products liability issues it addresses. The most significant issue it addresses is the triggering date for application of the strict liability statute (which is the date of sale of the product, and not the manufacture date).

FACTUAL BACKGROUND: The case involves a defective wheel assembly manufactured by Firestone Tire and Rubber Co. and sold to a trailer manufacturer. 302 S.C. at 367, 396 S.E.2d at 356. The wheel assembly's rim and ring were not designed to be used together. Id. The trailer manufacturer sold the trailer in question to Defendant Fruehauf Corp. ("Fruehauf") in used condition. Id. Fruehauf repaired and reconditioned the trailer, including the tires, but did not break down the wheel assemblies. Id. Fruehauf then sold the trailer to Defendant Piedmont ("Piedmont"), who leased it to Plaintiff's employer. Id. Plaintiff was injured when he attempted to place the wheel assembly on the axle of a trailer. Id. The wheel rim and side ring separated, striking Plaintiff in the head and causing severe head trauma. Id.

PROCEDURE: Plaintiff settled his claim against Firestone for $675,000, with a guarantee of $200,000 if he did not recover against the other parties. 302 S.C. 367, 396 S.E.2d at 356. Plaintiff brought an action against Fruehauf and Piedmont and won $1,125,000 in actual damages against both defendants. Id., 396 S.E.2d at 355. The verdict against Fruehauf was based on strict liability and negligence, and the verdict against Piedmont was based on strict liability only. Id., 396 S.E.2d at 356. Plaintiff also won $1,125,000 in punitive damages from Fruehauf. Id., 396 S.E.2d at 355. The jury also found for Piedmont with regard to its indemnification cross claim against Fruehauf. Id.

ISSUES: The appellate issues that are most substantive in terms of products liability law are as follows: (1) whether strict liability applied where the wheel assembly was placed in the stream of commerce prior to July 9, 1974 (the effective date of the strict liability statute); (2) whether a supplier of a defective product can be liable for negligence if there is no privity between the supplier and injured party; (3) whether the trial court's decision to deny Fruehauf's motions for directed verdict and j.n.o.v. concerning certain issues and submit them to the jury was proper; (4) whether the jury's award of punitive damages against Fruehauf in a strict liability case was proper; and (5) whether the trial judge erred in submitting Piedmont's cross claim for indemnity to the jury. 302 S.C. at 368-71, 396 S.E.2d at 356-58.

RULES AND OPINION: With regard to the first issue, the court disagreed that the manufacture dates of the mismatched ring (1968) and rim (1972) were the pertinent dates for triggering application of the strict liability statute. 302 S.C. at 368, 396 S.E.2d at 356. "The pertinent date to determine [the strict liability statute's] application is the date the product was sold by the seller," and not the manufacture date." Id. (citing Schall v. Sturm, Ruger Co., 278 S.C. 646, 300 S.E.2d 735 (1983)). Since Fruehauf sold the trailer to Piedmont in 1976 and Piedmont leased the trailer in 1979, the strict liability statute applied. 302 S.C. at 369, 396 S.E.2d at 356.

The court also disagreed with Fruehauf's contention that Plaintiff failed to establish that Fruehauf owed him a duty of care since it did not design or manufacture the wheel assembly and was merely a seller. 302 S.C. at 369, 396 S.E.2d at 357. "In South Carolina, . . . the supplier of a defective product is accountable to an injured party on ordinary negligence principles despite a lack of privity." Id. (citing Carolina Home Builders, Inc. v. Armstrong Furnace Co., 259 S.C. 346, 191 S.E.2d 774 (1972)).

The court agreed with the trial court's decision to deny Fruehauf's motions for directed verdict and j.n.o.v. with regard to the issue of whether it breached its duty of care. Id. The evidence supported that Fruehauf was aware of the danger of a mismatched rim as early as 1963 and failed to properly inspect the wheel assembly. Id. Therefore, the issue of breach of duty was properly submitted to the jury. Id. Similarly, there was evidence that Plaintiff's employer warned him to put the tires in a cage before inflating them to avoid exploding rims. 302 S.C. at 369-70, 396 S.E.2d at 357. Therefore, whether Plaintiff assumed the risk or was contributorily negligent were also issues for the jury, and the trial court properly denied Fruehauf's directed verdict and j.n.ov. motions on these issues. Id.

With regard to Fruehauf's punitive damages issue, the court agreed that Barnwell v. Barber Colman Co., 301 S.C. 534, 393 S.E.2d 162 (1989) disallowed punitive damages in an action based solely on strict liability. 302 S.C. at 370, 396 S.E.2d at 357. However, in this case, the jury found Fruehauf liable on both strict liability and negligence causes of action. Id. Punitive damages are recoverable in a negligence cause of action when the conduct rises to the level of a willful, wanton or malicious violation of the plaintiff's rights. Id. (citing Harris v. Burnside, 261 S.C. 190, 199 S.E.2d 65 (1973)). From the evidence, the jury could have reached this conclusion, so the court affirmed the award. Id.

Finally, the court agreed that the trial judge erred in submitting Piedmont's cross claim for indemnification to the jury. Id. Fruehauf and Piedmont shared a common liability to Plaintiff under South Carolina' strict liability law. 302 S.C. at 371, 396 S.E.2d at 358. Both contributed to Plaintiff's injury by selling a defective product. Id. "Parties that have no legal relation to one another and who owe the same duty of care to the injured party share a common liability and are joint tortfeasors without a right of indemnity between them." Id. (citing Atlantic Coast Line R.R. v. Whetstone, 243 S.C. 61, 132 S.E.2d 172 (1963)). This principle required reversal of the trial court's decision. Id. Since both defendants were jointly liable, the court also held that each was entitled to benefit from the setoff for the $675,000 Firestone settlement. Id. The setoff should apply to the award for actual damages instead of the punitive damages award. Id.

This post is subject to the DISCLAIMER & TERMS OF USE of this website.

Monday, October 12, 2009

Case Brief: Duncan v. Ford Motor Company

By Brian A. Comer

At long last, here is the case brief for Ford v. Duncan. Sorry for the delay (and length...there is a lot to this case). I will circle back around and drop in citations once the case is published. In the meantime, you can find it here.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND: A fire, originating under the hood of Plaintiffs' 2000 Ford Expedition, destroyed Plaintiffs' home on March 1, 2005. Evidence was presented at trial that Ford had recalled two lines of vehicles because of under-hood fires (one in 1999, and one in 2005). Ford attributed the under-hood fires to a certain failure of the speed control deactivation switch (the "switch"), which was manufactured by Texas Instruments ("TI") and installed by Ford. One month after the 1999 recall, a group of scientists employed by Ford produced an internal document that analyzed causes of the fires and proposed solutions. Ford acknowledged in the report that it did not completely understand the cause of the fires, but the report identified a failure in the switch as a potential cause. Ford did not implement any of the report's proposed solutions and did not address the switch failure during the 1999 recall.

At trial, Ford's expert, Mark Hoffman, testified that Ford did not incorporate the proposed solutions because it determined the switch failure and subsequent fires were caused by manufacturing problems at TI. Mr. Hoffman testified that Ford ensured that TI resolved its manufacturing issues, and it replaced any switches that deviated from its specifications. Plaintiffs' expert Jeff Morrill testified that (1) the switch in Plaintiffs' vehicle was the same type of switch that was in the line of vehicles recalled in 1999, (2) the fire was caused by the same failure in the switch as the one that caused the failure in the 1999 recall, and (3) Ford knew of the switch failure before manufacturing Plaintiffs' vehicle, as evidenced by the 1999 recall and the internal report. Plaintiffs' then called their engineering expert Kendrick Richardson, who testified that Ford breached the engineering standard of care. Plaintiffs also offered a report by economist Oliver Wood relating to Ford's net worth and ability to pay a punitive damages award.
PROCEDURE: Plaintiffs brought suit against Defendant Ford. The jury returned a verdict in Plaintiffs' favor, awarding them $620,759.79 in actual damages, reduced to $589,721.80 in proportion to Plaintiffs' comparative fault, and $3 million in punitive damages. Ford appealed the verdict.

ISSUES: Ford's arguments on appeal related to the trial court's admission of certain evidence and the jury's award of punitive damages.
  • With regard to the admission of evidence, Ford argued that the trial court (1) erred by allowing Plaintiffs' expert Jeff Morrill to present design opinions; (2) erred by allowing Plaintiffs to ask Plaintiffs' expert Kendrick Richardson whether Ford breached its engineering standard of care based on Mr. Morrill's conclusions; (3) erred by preventing Ford from asking Plaintiffs' experts, Morrill and Richards, who manufactured the switch and why Ford decided to recall the line of vehicles in 1999; (4) erred by admitting the 19999 recall of the line of vehicles into evidence; (5) erred by submitting Plaintiff Anna Duncan's claim for emotional distress to the jury in the absence of expert testimon; and (6) abused its discretion by not admitting Jack Threadgill's appraisal of the Plaintiffs home into evidence because it qualified as a business record.

  • Ford contended that the jury's award of punitive damages should be reversed because (1) Ford's conduct did not rise to the level of reckless, willful, or wanton conduct, and (2) the trial court should have instructed the jury not to consider conduct occurring outside of South Carolina or harm to non-parties when deciding whether to award punitive damages, (3) the trial court should not have allowed economist Oliver Wood to testify because his testimony invited the jury to return an award of punitive damages against it based solely on its financial well-being, and (4) Ford's conduct satisfied the guideposts set forth in BMW of North America, Inc. v. Gore, 517 U.S. 559 (1996).
DISPOSITION: The South Carolina Court of Appeals affirmed the decision of the circuit court.

RULES AND OPINION: With regard to Ford's evidentiary arguments, the South Carolina Court of Appeals found as follows:

(1) Plaintiffs' expert Jeff Morrill testified within his area of expertise (i.e., the cause and origin of the fire), and he never offered any design opinions. Morrill's testimony about the switch failure was not that it was defectively designed, but that it was the cause of the fire. Furthermore, he relied on the internal report to provide this opinion, and therefore he could testify about it (despite not having firsthand knowledge of the report, and despite not having worked at Ford).

(2) The trial court did not abuse its discretion by allowing Plaintiffs' expert Kendrick Richardson to respond to the hypothetical question of whether Ford breached its engineering standard of care, based on Morrill's conclusions. As stated before, Morrill was qualified to offer his testimony. Plaintiffs' posing of this question to Richardson at trial was not misleading--even though it omitted the manufacturing problems at TI--because it was based on Morrill's testimony and the internal report, neither of which referred to manufacturing issues at TI.

(3) The trial court did not err in preventing Ford from asking Morrill and Richardson who manufactured the switch and why Ford decided to recall the line of vehicles in 1999. "A manufacturer who incorporates into his product a component made by another has a responsibility to test and inspect such components, and his negligent failure to properly perform such duty renders him liable for injuries proximately caused as a consequence." (citing Nelson v. Coleman Co., 249 S.C. 652, 657, 155 S.E.2d 917, 920 (1967)). Because Ford incorporated the switch manufactured by TI, it was legally responsible for it in the event that it failed and caused damage. For this reason, the fact that TI made the switch was irrelevant. In addition, Ford produced no evidence that its 1999 recall was prompted by manufacturing problems at TI. Even if the trial court committed error in precluding this line of questioning, Ford was not prejudiced.

(4) The trial court did not abuse its discretion by allowing the 1999 recall into evidence. The evidence indicated that the under-hood fires that prompted the 1999 recall of the other line of Ford vehicles were substantially similar to the under-hood fires in the Plaintiffs' Expedition. (Citing Whaley v. CSX Transp., Inc. 362 S.C. 356, 483, 609 S.E.2d 286, 300 (2005) (noting other incidents must be substantially similar to be relevant and admissible in a products liability action)).

(5) The court did not find error with regard to submission of Plaintiff Anna Duncan's claim for emotional distress to the jury in the absence of expert testimony. The jury verdict of $620,759.79 was less than the evidence of actual damages presented at trial (exclusive of the claim for emotional distress), and therefore the verdict should not be disturbed on appeal. (Citing Burns v. Universal Health Servs., Inc., 361 S.C. 221, 232, 603 S.E.2d 605, 611 (Ct. App. 2004)).

(6) The trial court did not abuse its discretion by excluding Jack Threadgill's appraisal of Plaintiffs' home from evidence. Ford sought to introduce the document to show the value Threadgill assigned to Plaintiff's home, and the business records exception does not allow subjective opinions within documents to be introduced into evidence. (Citing S.C. R. Evid. 803(6)). Threadgill's appraisal was a subjective opinion.

With regard to Ford's punitive damages arguments, the South Carolina Court of Appeals found as follows:

(1) The court upheld that clear and convincing evidence concerning Ford's conduct supported the jury's award of punitive damages. As stated by the court:

Under South Carolina law, punitive damages may be awarded to punish torfeasors who have acted in a "reckless, willful, or wanton" manner. The plaintiff must prove punitive damages by clear and convincing evidence. Clear and convincing evidence is: "that degree of proof which will produce in the mind of the trier of facts a firm belief as to the allegations sought to be established." The clear and convincing standard is the highest burden of proof known to civil law.
(Citations omitted). Based on this standard, the court found that Ford knew that the switch it installed could fail and that the failures were causing fires before its manufacture of Plaintiffs' vehicle. Ford's knowledge and failure to make any changes to the switch rose to the level of reckless, willful, and wanton conduct.

(2) The court did not believe that the evidence or the arguments in the case required that the trial court charge the jury "not to consider conduct occurring outside of South Carolina or harm to non-parties when decideing whether to award punitive damages." The Due Process Clause requires this charge only when there is a risk that a jury may award punitives for conduct occurring outside the state for harm to non-parties. The recalls introduced into evidence by the plaintiffs were introduced for notice and to show that a prior recall was due to the same type of failure. Plaintiffs introduced evidence to show the reprehensible nature of Ford's conduct, and not to show the number of vehicles recalled or the number of under-hood fires.

(3) The court disagreed that Oliver Wood's expert testimony about Ford's general wealth and ability to pay a punitive damages award was inadmissible. The court cited to prior authority in which testimony beyond a defendant's mere net worth was allowed to establish the defendant's ability to pay a punitive damages award. The court also stated that Dr. Wood's testimony allowed the jury to follow the court's instructions and "punish the defendant but not effect bankruptcy."

(4) The court reviewed the procedural and substantive constitutional limitations on the award of punitive damages as set forth in BMW of N. Am., Inc. v. Gore, 517 U.S. 559, 562 (1996). With regard to reprehensibility of conduct, the court noted that the damage was economic (destruction of the house), as opposed to physical, which weighed in Ford's favor. However, in spite of this, the court found that Ford's conduct was reprehensible because:


In short, Ford installed a switch into the [Plaintiffs'] Expedition that it knew could cause fires. This conduct clearly amounts to a reckless disregard for the health and safety of others. . . . While Ford's conduct did not rise to the level of intentional malice, trickery, or deceit, Ford's act of installing a switch in the [Plaintiffs'] Expedition that it knew could cause fires amounts to affirmative misconduct.

The court also found the award to be reasonable (with regard to Gore's second factor). The economic harm, combined with the threat of serious physical injury, made the punitive damages award that was 5.087 times the actual damages reasonable. Finally, in examining Gore's third factor regarding comparable civil fines, the court found that the jury's award of three million dollars in punitive damages was not unconstitutionally excessive.

This post is subject to the DISCLAIMER & TERMS OF USE of this website.