Showing posts with label Food Warnings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Food Warnings. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

Article Published in SCDTAA Publication "The Defense Line"

I am pleased to announce that my article entitled "Limits on the Duty to Warn in South Carolina Products Liability Law" was recently published in the Spring 2011 edition of The Defense Line, which is published by the South Carolina Defense Trial Attorneys' Association. You can find a .pdf of the article here.

As background, South Carolina Lawyer was kind enough to publish my article, "South Carolina Products Liability Law: What is South Carolina's Law on Warnings?" in its January 2011 edition. (See my post about this publication here). The original draft of the article was intended to be a comprehensive review of South Carolina warnings law, with the exception of the doctrine of preemption (which is a topic for an entirely different article by itself). The problem was that the article was extremely long and nearly double the word limitations requested by South Carolina Lawyer. To prepare it for publication, I had to cut a substantial amount of material from the section dealing with exceptions to and limitations on the duty to warn. My hope was that I could use this material to create a separate article and have it published in a different publication.

Fast forward to the Spring edition of The Defense Line, and there you have it: the "lost material" from the original article. This article has substantially more information on limitations/exceptions to the duty to warn in South Carolina than what was in the original South Carolina Lawyer article, with more case law and analysis. Enjoy.

This post is subject to the DISCLAIMER AND TERMS OF USE of this website.

Friday, February 4, 2011

SC Lawyer Article on Warnings Published

My apologies for the length of time since my last post. January was rough for the South Carolina Products Liability Law Blog, as your beloved author got sidetracked by one kid getting sick...for a week...then a second kid getting sick...for the entire next week....and then yours truly getting the flu this past week (most likely thanks to aforementioned kids). So basically, when I haven't been working, I've been helping tend to sick kids or trying to get myself healthy again. Fun stuff, people, fun stuff. But better days are ahead, as Punxsutawney Phil did NOT see his shadow this week, meaning spring is on the way!

But enough about all that. Let's talk about something that really gets the juices flowing...like South Carolina's law on warnings. South Carolina Lawyer was kind enough to publish my article entitled Products Liability Claims in South Carolina: What is South Carolina's Law on Warnings? in its January 2011 edition, and you can find a copy of it here (give it a couple seconds to load). This article started out as a very exhaustive look at South Carolina warnings law (with the exception of the doctrine of preemption...which is a big enough topic to be its own article). However, because of space constraints, I had to cut it down a fair amount for publication. The section on exceptions to the duty to warn was originally much longer and had a great deal of additional case law and information. Because much of this information had to be cut out, I plan to use it as the basis for a new article that focuses specifically on this area of South Carolina warnings law, and I hope to submit it for publication in the near future.

Hopefully you will find it to be of interest, and I welcome any comments or feedback.

A couple of other blog-worthy developments from the last month. The South Carolina Defense Trial Attorneys Association asked if I would co-chair the Products Liability Substantive Law Committee, which I was very happy to accept for this year. My co-chair is Nick Gladd, and we will be responsible for providing updates to the organization on developments in products liability law in South Carolina, as well as helping plan for certain breakout sessions at the SCDTAA's meetings this year. If any followers of the blog are members of the SCDTAA and have suggestions for breakout topics, then please let me know.

Finally, my firm has asked me to chair our Products Liability Practice Group. The outgoing chairperson is Gray Culbreath, who also happens to be the Managing Partner of Collins & Lacy, P.C. and serves as the current President of the SCDTAA. Needless to say, Gray is wearing many different hats these days, so I appreciated my firm asking me to take over this duty so as to free him up a bit. I look forward to serving in this role.

This post is subject to the DISCLAIMER AND TERMS OF USE of this website.

Thursday, December 9, 2010

'Tis the Season for Good Food...And Warnings



During this time of year when we enjoy turkey, turkey ala king, turkey sandwiches, turkey soup, turkey casserole, and crazy delicious holiday food (see above classic example from National Lampoon's "Christmas Vacation"), it is a good time to reflect on...warnings. Yes, that's right, there is even a body of law concerning warnings about food.

You are probably saying to yourself right now, "I've always thought that the turkey packaging should warn about L-Tryptophan and the danger of driving after Christmas lunch." Whether sleepiness after excessive turkey consumption is an open and obvious risk (and therefore constitutes an exception to the duty to warn) is an issue that will be debated for eons among the most sophisticated jurists.

But I digress. The reality is that food warnings law is set forth fairly clearly in comment J. to section 402A of the Restatement (Second) of Torts. As you will recall, South Carolina has incorporated this comment by reference into its strict liability statute as the legislative intent of the chapter. See S.C. Code Ann. § 15-73-30 (1976) (“Comments to § 402A of the Restatement of Torts, Second, are incorporated herein by reference thereto as the legislative intent of this chapter.”). Comment j. includes certain exceptions to the duty to warn, and it just so happens that two such exceptions deal with warnings about food.

(1) Common Allergies

The first exception to the duty to warn set forth in comment j. is that “the seller may reasonably assume that those with common allergies, as for example to eggs or strawberries, will be aware of them, and he is not required to warn against them.” Restatement (Second) of Torts § 402A cmt. j. Although this exception to the duty to warn may be straightforward when the consumer’s conduct relates to avoiding individual food products, it becomes more problematic when these food products are ingredients in other dishes. Comment j. therefore qualifies this exception with additional language.
Where, however, the product contains an ingredient to which a substantial number of the population are allergic, and the ingredient is one whose danger is not generally known, or if known is one which the consumer would reasonably not expect to find in the product, the seller is required to give warning against it, if he has knowledge, or by the application of reasonable, developed human skill and foresight should have knowledge of the presence of the ingredient and the danger.
For example, the Food Allergen Labeling and Consumer Act (“FALCA”) went into effect in 2006 to require that packaged foods containing milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, peanuts, tree nuts, wheat and soy must display them prominently in the ingredient list. See 21 U.S.C. § 201 et. seq. According to FALCA, these “Big Eight” food allergens account for 90 percent of all food-allergic reactions, and federal law requires their disclosure on packaged foods. Id. at § 201(2). Comment j. provides some of the rationale for this disclosure: a substantial number of the population is allergic to these ingredients, and the consumer may not know if one of the ingredients is in a food product without the disclosure.

Neither South Carolina state nor federal courts have interpreted this specific aspect of comment j. in the context of a food products failure to warn case. However, in Vaughn v. Nissan Motor Corp., 77 F.3d 736, 738 (4th Cir. 1996), the court stated in dicta that the “ordinary consumer” standard for determining if a product is unreasonably dangerous does not necessarily apply in the case of products associated with allergic reactions in an appreciable number of consumers.

(2) Products Consumed Over a Long Period of Time

Comment j. also carves out an exception to the duty to warn if the potential danger of a product relates to its use over a long period of time or in excessive quantities: “[A] seller is not required to warn with respect to products, or ingredients in them, which are only dangerous, or potentially so, when consumed in excessive quantity, or over a long period of time, when the danger, or potentiality of danger, is generally known and recognized.” Restatement (Second) of Torts § 402A cmt. j. As examples, the comment cites to alcoholic beverages and foods containing substances such as saturated fats. A seller has no duty to warn about the risks associated with such products from extended or excessive consumption.

Neither South Carolina state nor federal courts have interpreted this exception in comment j. In Aldana v. R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co., No. 2:06-3366-CWH, 2008 WL 1883404 (D.S.C. Apr. 25, 2008), the court cited to this portion of comment j. to support that the warnings for defendant’s cigarette products were not required to make the product itself “safe,” but the court did not otherwise apply it to excessive or extended use of cigarettes. Id. at *2.

From the South Carolina Products Liability Law Blog, here's wishing you and your friends/families a very Merry Christmas and happy holiday season.

This post is subject to the DISCLAIMER AND TERMS OF USE of this website.