Tuesday, February 12, 2013

Verdict Survey: Chicken Sandwich in Cherokee County

Remember that blog about me posting regular content in the form of verdict surveys every week?  Yeah, me neither.  Sorry for the hiatus.  This week's verdict survey involves a hot chicken sandwich.

Capsule Summary: A Cherokee County jury returned a defense verdict in a claim brought by a male plaintiff in his mid-forties in which he alleged the chicken sandwich he purchased from a Burger King was too hot and caused second degree burns to his gums.

Case Information: Frank Chancellor v. Carrols Corporation d/b/a Burger King Restaurants, Civil Action Number 2008CP1100139.

Date of Verdict: March 3, 2010.

Venue: Cherokee County Court of Common Pleas

Judge: The Honorable J. Mark Hayes, II

Factual Background: A father went with his son to a Burger King Restaurant owned by the defendant, Carrols Corporation.  The plaintiff placed a carryout order for a kid's meal for his son and a chicken sandwich for himself.  Once they were on the road, the plaintiff unwrapped the chicken sandwich and took a bite.  The bite of sandwich lodged in an area of the plaintiff's mouth where he was missing some teeth, and he alleged it caused second degree burns to his gums.

Allegations and Procedure:  Plaintiff filed his lawsuit in the Cherokee County Court of Common Pleas.  He alleged a cause of action for breach of warranty of merchantability on grounds that the sandwich was too hot.  The defendant argued that customers wanted their sandwiches to be hot.  They also argued the plaintiff's actions were inconsistent with his allegations, especially by the fact that he did not seek treatment from his doctor for the alleged injury.

Experts: None listed.

Alleged Damages:  Plaintiff was a married male in his mid-forties.  He was employed by General Electric.  He alleged $1,500 in past medical special damages.

Disposition: After 15 minutes of deliberation, the jury returned a defense verdict.

This post is subject to the DISCLAIMER AND TERMS OF USE of this website.

Tuesday, January 29, 2013

2013 DRI Products Liability Conference


Since 2010, I have made it a priority to attend the Defense Research Institute's Products Liability Conference.  This year's conference is being held April 3-5, 2013, in the Washington, D.C. area at Gaylord National Resort and Convention Center in National Harbor, Maryland.  As this is the time of the year when the cherry blossoms bloom in the Washington D.C. area, the theme of this year's conference is "Make Your Products Liability Practice Bloom." 

This conference is always outstanding.  I try to attend it each year because (1) the programming keeps me updated from a practice standpoint, and (2) now that I have attended for a few years, there are more and more "familiar faces" for networking purposes. 

In addition, I am in my second year serving as the Agricultural, Construction, Mining and Industrial Equipment ("ACMIE") Specialized Litigation Group ("SLG") co-chair.  We always have a breakout session at this conference, and there are some great topics and speakers this year.  Members Kurt Meaders (Sedgwick LLP) and Jaime Myers (Caterpillar Inc.) will present a program entitled "Shifting Gears on the Opposition's Experts--Deposition, Daubert, and Trial."  This presentation will focus on strategy for dealing with plaintiff's experts at the discovery, dispositive motion, and trial stages.  Emily Muceus (Deere & Company) and Robert Walker (Gallagher Walker Bianco & Plastaras) will present a program entitled "From the Trenches: Trial Strategies in High Exposure, Bad Venue ACMIE Cases."  As its title suggests, this program is designed to arm our members with trial tactics that can assist in defending the toughest ACMIE cases at trial.  Finally, we will do our annual "Top 10" ACMIE cases, which will be presented by Christopher Robinson (Frost Brown Todd, LLC).  Our SLG program is planned for April 3, 2013 from 3:30 to 5:30 p.m.

If you have not already registered, I would urge you to plan to attend this conference and participate in our SLG meeting.  All of the information about the conference and registration can be found at this link, and I hope you will make plans to attend.  

Monday, December 31, 2012

Holiday Case Brief and Verdict Survey: Gasque v. Heublein, Inc.

I hope you have enjoyed the holidays and are ready for the new year.  This has been one of my busiest times around the holidays in awhile, but I could not miss the opportunity to do a holiday season "food" post.  Last year, I tried to do a comprehensive series about South Carolina's products liability law in the context of food cases.  However, I missed one of the more interesting cases, and I thought it would be blogworthy at this time of year (especially in light of the amount of wine and champagne that will be consumed this evening).  Gasque v. Heublein, Inc., 281 S.C. 278, 315 S.E.2d 556 (Ct. App. 1984) involves a cork that prematurely ejected and caused injury to a plaintiff's eye.  An Horry County jury returned a verdict for $750,000, and the South Carolina Court of Appeals affirmed the verdict.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND: Plaintiff sustained permanent loss of vision in his left eye when he was struck by the stopper and cork assembly of a bottle of Jacques Bonet Cold Duck sparkling wine.    281 S.C. at 281, 315 S.E.2d at 558.  The stopper allegedly ejected prematurely when Plaintiff's friend was twisting the wire retaining hood on the cork.  Id.

PROCEDURE: Plaintiff brought suit against the manufacturer-bottlers ("Defendants") of the sparkling wine, as well as three other defendants in the chain of distribution.  281 S.C. at 281, 315 S.E.2d at 558.  Plaintiff asserted causes of action for negligence, warranty, and strict liability, and he sought actual and punitive damages.  Id.  The case was submitted to the jury on the theories of negligence and strict liability.  Id.  The jury returned a general verdict for $750,000 in actual damages against Defendants.  Id.   

ISSUES: There were three issues on appeal: (1) whether the trial court erred in submitting the issues of negligent (a) design, (b) manufacture, (c) inspection, and (d) failure to warn; (2) whether the trial court erred in admitting into evidence a filmed experiment conducted by Plaintiff's expert; and (3) whether the trial court erred in failing to grant Defendants' motion for a new trial absolute on grounds that the verdict was actuated by passion, prejudice and caprice.  281 S.C. at 281, 315 S.E.2d at 558. 

DISPOSITION: The South Carolina Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court on all three issues.

OPINION: The appellate court addressed each of the issues in the order in which they were raised, as set forth below.

(1) Submission of Negligence Theories

With regard to negligent design, Plaintiff presented reports of studies commissioned by one of the Defendants concerning premature ejection of champagne stoppers.  281 S.C. at 282, 315 S.E.2d at 559.  The reports identified the problem of premature ejection and suggested design alternatives to correct it.  Id. at 282-83, 315 S.E.2d at 559.  Defendants' Quality Control Director also testified that before Defendants' switched from wood stoppers to polyethylene stoppers, they had no reports of injuries.  Id.  One of the reports also discussed the various problems with polyethylene stoppers versus wood stoppers.  Id.  In short, the evidence showed Defendants were aware of the problem of premature ejection, knew about feasible alternative designs, were aware that wood corks were safer, and elected to use an undrilled and uncoated polyethylene stopper to retain the festive "pop" of the cork.  Id. at 283, 315 S.E.2d at 559.  Plaintiff also presented expert testimony in support of his theory.  Id. at 284, 315 S.E.2d at 559.  The evidence was sufficient to submit the issue of negligent design to the jury.

With regard to negligent manufacture, Plaintiff presented the cork at issue and had his expert testify there was a groove on it that was distinguishable from other stoppers.  Id. at 284, 315 S.E.2d at 560.  Plaintiff's expert testified the groove was caused by improper attachment of the wire retainer to the stopper during manufacture, and this manufacturing defect contributed to premature ejection.  Id.  Based on this evidence, the court upheld submission of negligent manufacture to the jury.  Id.

With regard to negligent inspection, the court concluded that the testimony of Defendants' Quality Control Director supported submission of this issue to the jury.  Id. at 285, 315 S.E.2d at 560.  The director testified a pressure check was performed on only one out of every 30,000 to 40,000 bottles, and quality control personnel had only one or two seconds to ascertain whether or not the wire hood was properly attached to the stopper.  Id.

With regard to negligent failure to warn, the court concluded that the warning at issue was approximately 1/8 the size of the print used to advertise the product's name, and it did not mention premature ejection (just that the contents were under high pressure and that the bottle should be pointed away).  Id.  The court held the language of the warning, its placement, and print size created a jury question as to its adequacy.  Id.  The issue of negligent failure to wan was properly submitted to the jury.  Id.

(2) Admission Into Evidence of Filmed Experiment

To be admissible at trial, an experiment or test must have been made under conditions and circumstances substantially similar to those prevailing at the time of the occurrence involved in the controversy.  Id. at 286, 315 S.E.2d at 560 (citing Weaks v. South Carolina State Highway Dep't, 250 S.C. 535, 159 S.E.2d 234 (1968)).  Plaintiff's expert introduced a filmed experiment conducted by his expert where a stopper in the product at issue spontaneously ejected when the expert began twisting the wire retaining hood.  Id.  The trial judge allowed the jury to view the experiment.  Id.  Defendants argued the admission was error because the experiment utilized champagne (instead of sparkling wine), involved a different size bottle, and had different temperatures.  Id. at 286, 315 S.E.2d 560-61.  Plaintiff's expert testified the properties the experimental bottle were substantially the same.  Id., 315 S.E.2d at 561. 

The court noted that admission of evidence is a matter for the trial judge's discretion and will not be disturbed absent abuse of discretion.  Id.  The court also noted that Defendants vigorously cross examined the expert on the distinctions between the experiment and and facts of the case.  Id. at 287, 315 S.E.2d at 561.  The court held the conditions of the filmed experiment were substantially similar to those existing at the time of injury.  Id.  However, even if they were not, this issue did not warrant reversal because the experiment was cumulative of other evidence introduced by Plaintiff (including testimony of the friend who opened the bottle, experts, and the information contained in Defendants' reports about premature ejection).  Id. (citing Beasley v. Kerr-McGee Chem. Corp., 273 S.C. 523, 257 S.E.2d 726 (1979)).

(3) Excessiveness of Verdict

The court noted it has limited power to interfere with verdict amounts, which are left almost entirely to the judge and jury.  Id. at 287, 315 S.E.2d at 561 (citing Charles v. Texas Co., 199 S.C. 156, 18 S.E.2d 719, 729 (1942)).  The court cannot reduce a verdict, and it will only strike a verdict down completely if the amount is so shockingly excessive as to indicate it is the result of passion, caprice, and prejudice.  Id.  In view of the severity and permanency of Plaintiff's injury, the court did not find the verdict of $750,000 to be excessive.  Id. at 288, 315 S.E.2d at 562.  In short, there was substantial evidence concerning Plaintiff's pain, multiple surgeries, impact on vision, and change in lifestyle.  Id. at 288-89, 315 S.E.2d at 562.  Based on the evidence, the court did not find the verdict to be excessive.  It also reviewed verdicts for loss of vision cases elsewhere that were also similar to the jury's verdict.  Id.

This post is subject to the DISCLAIMER AND TERMS OF USE of this website.

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Catching Up and Latest Publication

Apologies are in order from the South Carolina Products Liability Law Blog.  I was able to do a flurry of posts back in November, which helped me catch up on quite a bit of blogging.  However, with the holiday season and with many of my cases rearing their heads in December, it has been difficult to post lately.  (The image posted with this blog is one of the images you find when you do a google image search of "tired" and "Santa").

So...what's new?  The webinar for Primerus went very well, as we had about thirty people who virtually "attended" and followed the presentation.  I am sure the Primerus Products Liability Executive Committee will plan some similar presentations in 2013, so stay tuned on that front.  You may also recall my fortieth birthday was the same day as the presentation.  Luckily, I managed to get through the entirety of my portion without having an episode of memory loss.  (That was a joke...you can laugh). 

In addition, my colleague Kristian Cross and I authored an article entitled "Managing Litigation Risk: Practice Pointers From 'Soup to Nuts'" in the most recent edition of the Association of Corporate Counsel (South Carolina Chapter) e-newsletter.  You can find it at this link. 

Finally, one of the things I regret about being so busy this December is that I have not been able to do a food-centered holiday series.  (You can see prior posts in December 2010 and 2011 here and here).  However, I hope to get one or two up the latter part of this week, or maybe headed into the New Year.  Be sure to check back.

I hope everyone has a Merry Christmas and Happy New Year!

Thursday, November 22, 2012

Happy Thanksgiving from the South Carolina Products Liability Law Blog!


Happy Thanksgiving from the South Carolina Products Liability Law Blog!  Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday because I like to cook, I like to eat, and I really do not like to shop.  Therefore, it is right up my alley.

I have a few traditions for each Thanksgiving.  I enjoy a great meal, usually take a strong nap, watch a bit of whatever basketball or football games are on during the day, and I ALWAYS find time to watch Planes, Trains, and Automobiles.  Thanksgiving movies do not get the hype that Christmas movies do, but this one is a classic.  If you have never seen it, the nutshell is that a marketing executive's travel plans get derailed and he has to find alternative methods to get home for Thanksgiving.  Along, the way, he meets Dell Griffith...one of the great, annoying, loveable characters in movie history.  Dell also has a history, which Steve Martin's character does not learn about until the end.  It is a hysterical movie, and also pretty heart-warming.

Anyway, trailer above and funny scene below.  Happy Thanksgiving to everyone.


Wednesday, November 21, 2012

How I Fry a Turkey

Yesterday, I mentioned that I wrote a summary for a friend awhile back of how I fry a turkey.  I'm not saying this is the best way to fry a turkey, but this is how we roll at the South Carolina Products Liability Law Blog when it comes to turkey frying.

I have also learned some lessons about how to save some time on the clean-up, which I share below.  Fried turkey is crazy delicious, but be careful. 

TIPS BASED ON MY EXPERIENCE

PREPARATION:

First, I would not recommend a “Butterball” turkey for frying.  I’m not sure what it is about them, but I don’t think they fry up very well (especially if you are injecting marinade). 

Makes sure the turkey is fully thawed.  Then, rinse the turkey thoroughly.  A good way to do this is to put the turkey in your fryer pot and fill the pot with water to rinse it.  Once the water fully covers the turkey, take the turkey out and note where the water level drops to, and mark it.  Now you know how much oil you need to put in the fryer pot for your turkey to be submerged.  (This is just a way to save oil; you can put in as much oil as you want, but it increases clean-up and also increases the risk of overflow, which is very dangerous).

Dry the turkey thoroughly.  If there is any water on it, it will pop when you put it in the oil.  Make sure it is good and dry.

You don’t have to do anything, as fried turkey is delicious without any “extras.”  However, I use fat-free Italian dressing as my injectable marinade.  I strain the herbs out first, and then I inject the marinade throughout the turkey.  I also coat the outside of the turkey all over with the marinade.  After this step, I coat the turkey heavily with Tony Chachere’s Cajun seasoning.  After this preparation, put the turkey in the refrigerator overnight.

FRYING:

Do the frying of the turkey on the grass somewhere.  There will be a little popping and grease residue that gets out of the pot, and if you are doing it on concrete, it will get on there.  This is not a big deal, as it will wear off.  However, it also makes it easy to track oil into the house, which never goes well with the wife.  For this reason, I do it in my backyard on the grass.  Also, do it away from your house.  Plenty of people have burned their houses down while frying a turkey, so you don’t want to be one of them.  You don't have to be 100 yards away from your home, but the point is not to do it in your garage.  A back patio away from the house or in the yard is fine.

I use peanut oil.  I can’t speak to other kinds of oils.  The cardinal rule about oil is do not mix poultry and seafood oil.  Your turkey will taste fishy.  You can fry anything else with turkey (hushpuppies, vegetables, etc.).  However, if you are using oil that you have used in the past for seafood frying, my experience is you taste the seafood in the turkey.  

Before I put the bird in the oil, I give it a fresh coat of Tony Chachere's.  Some of it usually drips off overnight, so I like a good coating before putting it in the oil.  

As for the actual cooking, in my experience, the key to frying a turkey is watching the temperature and watching the time.  Generally, I fry my turkey at 325 degrees for three-and-a-half minutes per pound.  That being said, before I put the turkey in the oil, I heat it to about 350 degrees.  The reason is that when I put the cold turkey in the oil, it usually decreases the temperature a fair amount.  Therefore, I have it a little hotter at the beginning so that (hopefully) the equilibrium is about 325 degrees when the turkey is lowered in the oil.

As I cook, I compensate with more or less time depending on my ability to keep the temperature at 325.  If it gets too hot, I turn the burner off until the temperature comes down, and I may reduce the fry time a bit to compensate.  If it gets too cold, I turn the burner up and may add some frying time depending on how long it takes to get it back to 325.  The point is to watch your gauge and try to keep it around that temperature, and compensate as needed.   

When the turkey is ready, lift it out and set it on some paper towels to strain off.  I usually just let it sit outside on the paper towels for about 15 minutes to cool and drip off oil.  Then I slide it off the lowering tool into a pan, take it inside, and pick it off the bone.

If I am frying multiple things over a few days, I don’t bother with cleaning the oil out of the pot.  I just put it in a safe place to cool and store until the next day.

CLEAN-UP AND STORAGE OF OIL

I've always read that oil is good for a year, and I've practiced that and never had any issues.  I find turkeys get better with every fry because the oil is good and seasoned.

When you are done frying for good and want to clean up, I've found the following to be the easiest way:

Let oil cool completely.  Get someone to help you, and have one person hold an oil funnel while the other pours the oil out of the pot and back into the original container.  Try to keep from spilling the oil outside the funnel, because if you do, it can get on the side of the container in which you are storing the oil.  If this happens, you now have to clean up the container (in addition to everything else you are cleaning).  Lowe's sells turkey frying peanut oil in big containers.  I would recommend trying to buy it in one of those big containers because it makes clean-up easier.  If you have four or five containers of oil (as opposed to one large container), then you have to keep refilling.  This creates more and more chance to get the oil on the outside of the containers and increase clean-up time.  If you have one big container, then you can just tip the pot and pour until it is all out.

Unless you have large "chunks" of residue, I wouldn't bother much with filtering the oil.  All the big stuff sinks to the bottom anyway, so when you get to the end you can decide if you want to keep what's at the bottom (i.e., the seasoning) or pour it off.  I usually pour everything back into my container.  It makes for better-seasoned oil. 

For cleaning the pot, get some Dawn and a good brillo pad or other steel wool.  I would do this outside…you won't score points with your better half if you do it inside. 

If you have hot water outside, that’s awesome.  If not, rinse the pot with some cold water to get the big residue out, and do a quick scrub.  This is to get the big stuff.  Pour out the cold water, and then fill the pot with water again and put it on your burner.  Use the burner to heat the water nice and warm/hot.  Then, I use the pot as a basin to clean my lowering tools, thermometer, scooper, etc.  Then, I scrub the interior and exterior of the pot and lid really good with the water in it, scrubbing hard.  Then I pour off that hot water, and probably repeat a last time with cold water. 

I’m not going to lie: the clean-up is a pain.  It usually takes me about 30 minutes to an hour.  You don't have to use hot water, but it seems to clean better and it takes longer just using cold water (i.e., you usually have to repeat it a couple more times).

(Because the clean-up takes a bit, I take advantage of every time I use my turkey fryer.  I will fry a turkey, a chicken, some hushpuppies, and maybe some other food to freeze). 

I store my oil inside until the next use.  I've kept it outside before in a storage room, and it got very cold.  I never had a spoilage issue from storage temperature, but it is probably a better practice to store it inside.  

I hope this is helpful.  It has always worked for me.

Tuesday, November 20, 2012

It's Turkey Frying Season



I'm an avid turkey fryer.  I don't know who first came up with the idea of taking one of the leanest, healthiest meats and dunking it in a vat of hot peanut oil, but I salute you sir. 

I also always enjoy seeing this Allstate commercial around Thanksgiving.  I like the matter-of-fact way that Dennis Haysbert (a/k/a President Dennis Palmer and Pedro Cerrano) talks about how plenty of people will burn their houses down when they try to fry a turkey.  My suspicion is that this most often occurs when someone uses too much oil, and it overflows when they lower the turkey into the pot (not that I have any experience with that...).  If you want to see a great illustration of the danger (and in the interest of providing equal time to State Farm), check out this video. 

Does this risk make a turkey fryer a defective and unreasonably dangerous as a product?  Of course not.  However, you do need to be careful.  WMFB news ran a nice story last week about turkey fryer fires (and other deep fryer claims).  Unfortunately, South Carolina ranks tenth in the country when in comes to deep fryer fires. 

So...when you fire up that oil this season, do be careful.  You can find a link to the article here, and the actual article is cut and pasted below.  (A few years back, I did a summary for a friend of how I fry a turkey.  If I can dig it up, I'll try to post it tomorrow).

SC ranks in top 10 for Thanksgiving cooking fires

Posted: Nov 14, 2012 12:07 PM EST Updated: Nov 15, 2012 4:30 AM EST

While turkey frying is very popular, it puts people at risk for fryer related fires and injuries.

SOUTH CAROLINA (WMBF) - Thanksgiving produces more cooking fires, according to insurance claims, than any other day of the year, and South Carolinians are starting many of them.

According to State Farm claims data, grease and cooking-related claims more than double on Thanksgiving Day compared to an average day in November. South Carolina ranked in the top 10 states for cooking fires according to claims made over the past five years.

While turkey frying is very popular, it puts people at risk for fryer related fires and injuries. In fact, fire departments across the U.S. respond to more than 1,000 fires each year where a deep fryer is involved.
The National Fire Protection Association reports that deep fryer fires cause more than $15 million in property damage each year, not to mention the burn dangers related to splattered grease.

According to State Farm, the top 10 states for grease and cooking-related claims on Thanksgiving Day for the past five years (2007-2011) are:
  1. Texas
  2. Illinois
  3. New York
  4. Ohio
  5. Florida
  6. California
  7. Louisiana
  8. Pennsylvania
  9. Minnesota
  10. South Carolina
Copyright 2012 WMBF News. All rights reserved.

Monday, November 19, 2012

Upcoming December 12 "Milestone" and Webinar

On December 12, 2012, two BIG things are happening.  First, yours truly turns the big 4-0.  Yes, the 40th birthday is at hand.  Funny...I don't feel any different than I did at age 20.  The big difference is the change in responsibility.  A good friend and former colleague of mine, Will Thomas, and I once had a conversation once about getting older.  I have often laughed at his explanation because of the way he phrased it and also the accuracy of his statement.  Paraphrased, he said it best:
I don't feel much different than when I was in college.  I'm still as ready to go out with friends as the next guy...stay up late...have fun.  However, regardless of what I do the night before, come 7 a.m., my son is waking up.  And from then on, it's "on" regardless of what I want to do or how I feel.
Very true statement.  I'm older, and (hopefully) a little wiser, but no matter what I want to do with my time, when the chirrens wake up and it is time to go to work, it's "on."

The other "big" thing happening December 12th is I am assisting with another Primerus webinar.  As I have stated in prior posts, my firm is a proud member of the International Society of Primerus Law Firms, and I serve on the Products Liability Executive Committee for the Primerus Defense Institute.  Our committee is presenting this webinar, which is entitled "Emerging Trends and Developments in Products Liability Law."  More specifically, it will provide an overview of what makes a manufacturer liable for a product in relation to a third-party component manufacturer, or even a plaintiff (i.e., by virtue of alteration or modification).  I will be joined by other Primerus lawyers John Brydon and Jeremy Cook as we speak on this topic.

These webinars are easy ways to get a nice overview of various practice areas in a short (one hour) timeframe.  It is also FREE (which is also a big selling point for this blogger).  Therefore, if you are a Primerus member or practice in-house, I invite you to join us.  Registration can be found here.